We're in the market for a new reel specific for targeting muskie with blades, any blades, single, double, 7's through 13. We want one reel that can do it all well. If you're in the same boat we thought it would be useful to show you our decision making process to help you pick one too.
The first thing we want to ensure is that we can toss bucktails all day without tiring. At certain times of the year this is all we are going to be doing and in the past it's not something we have been able to do without breaks throwing something easier. Secondly, we want to ensure that we can still get high speeds of retrieve as speed triggers bites; especially early in the year. These are really the only two requirements we have. We will still compare other spec's between reels like price point, amount of drag, and number of bearings but these are secondary to the two main requirements.
First things first. In order to easily reel in big bucktails we will need a lot of power. These blades create a ton of resistance in the water and so our reel will need this power to overcome it. This means a low gear ratio. Currently, we have been using an Okuma Komodo 463 which has an IPT of 33" and a gear ratio of 6.3:1. This is an ok reel for smaller single blades and small doubles but it becomes incredibly difficult as you get into size 9's and up. Long durations of use need to be broken up with swimbait or glide bait use to not kill your arms. So, based on this experience we are looking for a gear ratio below 6:1. After searching the market for a few options we compiled the list below:
Make: Abu Garcia
Model: Revo Toro Beast T3
Power Handle: Y
Gear Ratio: 4.9:1
Line Retrieve Per Turn: 27"
Drag: 25 Lbs
Price: $330 USD
Make: Shimano
Model: Tranx 401A
Power Handle: N - Aftermarket $40 USD
Gear Ratio: 5.8:1
Line Retrieve Per Turn: 30"
Drag: 22 Lbs
Price: $320 USD
Make: Daiwa
Model: Prorex 400
Power Handle: Y
Gear Ratio: 5.3:1
Line Retrieve Per Turn: 28"
Drag: 26.5 Lbs
Price: $340 USD
Make: Daiwa
Model: Lexa TW 400
Power Handle: Y
Gear Ratio: 5.3:1
Line Retrieve Per Turn: 28"
Drag: 28.7
Price: $360 USD
Make: Okuma
Model: Komodo SS 463
Power Handle: Y
Gear Ratio: 6.3:1
Line Retrieve Per Turn: 33"
Drag: 30 Lbs
Price: $290
Note: Currently using this model
The second criteria we have is being able to achieve high speeds if we need it to trigger bites. Comparing the slowest and fastest reels on the list above we get the speeds mentioned below at various retrieve rates:
IPT: 27", 33"
RPM: 2 turn/s x 60s
Speed: 3240"/min (3 Mph), 3960"/min (3.75 Mph)
IPT: 27", 33"
RPM: 3 turn/s x 60s
Speed: 4860"/min (4.6 Mph), 5940"/min (5.6 Mph)
IPT: 27", 33"
RPM: 4 turn/s x 60s
Speed: 6480"/min (6 Mph), 7920"/min (7.5 Mph)
A higher IPT gives much higher speed on retrieve; but it is unlikely we will be able to get 4 turns/second with big blades on 33" IPT reels due to higher gear ratio. From experience we are likely only able to get at most 2-3 turns/second except with single blades. The limit of this speed is similar to 27" IPT at 4 turns/second but would also be much more work.
With the above in mind the best option for our criteria seems to be the Daiwa Prorex. While the Revo Toro Beast has a lower gear ratio it is slower making the speed requirement more challenging. On the other hand, the Tranx has a high retrieve speed but is still difficult to use big blades with (We had to consult with friends on this one).
The middle ground: Daiwa Prorex.
To experience a day of fishing with us be sure to check out our YouTube channel at the link below:
If you or someone you know is looking to get into fishing or you just want to become a more successful angler be sure to check out our "Zero To Hero Fishing Masterclass" for courses on everything fishing! The masterclass is built to help you learn how to find and catch fish like the pro's by providing all the information you need and a clear development path! Don't miss out check it out now at www.newwavefishingacademy.com/zero-to-hero
Have you ever wondered why lures don't come with instructions and wanted to know how to fish them? Look no further than our "How To Fish" series where you will learn what each bait is, how to use it, when and where it excels over other baits, our preferred setup to use it on, and the common mistakes anglers make when using it. www.newwavefishingacademy.com/how-to-fish